Overview of the principles of judging for the VPPA Artisan Project:
Scoring will be based on two criteria, each of the 2 criteria will contribute a maximum of 50% of the total score:
Impact and Visual Language
Does an image have an impact visually and how successful has the maker conveyed the Artisan Project Theme. Does it create in you a sense of emotion when you see it for the first time? How does the image affect you (laughter, sadness, anger, or other strong motions)? Is the image powerful, vibrant, creative, original? Is the visual language in relation to the theme compelling? Is the photographic art used well to convey the theme? Does the selected visual language (style, light, technique, and enhancement) support the intent of the image and expresses relevantly the definition of the theme?
Technical excellence / composition
Is the image professionally and technically strong? Is the lighting and posing (where applicable) done with excellence? Is the product (car, building, etc.) showcased with excellence? Is the post production management done with excellence (color balance, sharpness, retouching, and compositing where applicable)? Is the composition strong – and possibly innovative? Does the composition support the story of the image, hold the iewers’ attention to the image, and emphasize the theme of the image?